| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | Score | Brackets |
| 2016 | Conestoga | Elizabethtown | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 2017 | Conestoga | Landisville Hempfield | 4-0 | Brackets |
| 2018 | Wilson | Radnor | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 2019 | North Penn | Central Bucks West | 2-0 | Brackets |
| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | Score | Brackets |
| 1973 | West Snyder | Upper Moreland | 2-1 | |
| 1974 | Middleburg | Tulpehocken | 4-0 | |
| 1975 | Bethlehem Liberty | North Allegheny | 1-0 | |
| 1976 | State College | Bethlehem Freedom | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1977 | Elco | Bethlehem Liberty | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1978 | Fleetwood | Upper St. Clair | 4-0 | Brackets |
| 1979 | Elco | Harriton | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 1980 | Fleetwood | Radnor | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1981 | Mt. Lebanon | Elco | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1982 | Neshaminy Langhorne | Fleetwood | 2-1, OT | Brackets |
| 1983 | Bethlehem Freedom * | Trinity (D-7) * | 1-1 | Brackets |
| 1984 | Neshaminy | Lower Merion | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 1985 | Council Rock | Moon | 4-2 | Brackets |
| 1986 | Strath Haven | West Chester East | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 1987 | Lower Merion | Fox Chapel | 2-1, OT | Brackets |
| 1988 | Conestoga | Lower Merion | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 1989 | Downingtown | Mt. Lebanon | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 1990 | Fox Chapel | Downingtown | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 1991 | Strath Haven | Upper St. Clair | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 1992 | Wilson (D-3) | Strath Haven | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 1993 | Great Valley | Wilson | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 1994 | Neshaminy * | Bethel Park * | 2-2 | Brackets |
| 1995 | Strath Haven | Erie McDowell | 8-0 | Brackets |
| 1996 | Strath Haven | North Allegheny | 6-0 | Brackets |
| 1997 | Wilkes-Barre Coughlin | Erie Prep | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1998 | Downingtown | Peters Township | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 1999 | Downingtown | North Allegheny | 4-2 | Brackets |
| 2000 | North Allegheny | Emmaus | 1-0, OT | Brackets |
| 2001 | Strath Haven * | Erie Prep * | 1-1, 4OT | Brackets |
| 2002 | West Chester Henderson | Chartiers Valley | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 2003 | Upper St. Clair | West Chester East | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 2004 | Upper St. Clair | West Chester Henderson | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 2005 | Warwick | West Chester Henderson | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 2006 | Council Rock North | Manheim Township | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 2007 | Peters Township | Downingtown West | 2-1, OT | Brackets |
| 2008 | Downingtown West | Peters Township | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 2009 | Father Judge * | Central Dauphin * | 0-0 | Brackets |
| 2010 | Landisville Hempfield | Central Bucks East | 2-1 OT | Brackets |
| 2011 | Conestoga | Upper St. Clair | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 2012 | Upper St. Clair | Wilson | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 2013 | Upper St. Clair | Conestoga Valley | 4-0 | Brackets |
| 2014 | Peters Township | Great Valley | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 2015 | Central Bucks East | Seneca Valley | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 2016 | Lower Dauphin | Northwestern Lehigh | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2017 | Lower Dauphin | Northwestern Lehigh | 4-1 | Brackets |
| 2018 | West Allegheny | Strath Haven | 4-0 | Brackets |
| 2019 | Lower Dauphin | Strath Haven | 2-1 | Brackets |
| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | Score | Brackets |
| 1985 | Quaker Valley | Tulpehocken | 4-1 | Brackets |
| 1986 | Elco | Holy Ghost Prep | 1-0, OT | Brackets |
| 1987 | Tulpehocken | Dallas | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 1988 | Peters Township | Fleetwood | 4-2 | Brackets |
| 1989 | Peters Township * | Great Valley * | 0-0 | Brackets |
| 1990 | Hampton * | Great Valley * | 0-0 | Brackets |
| 1991 | Quaker Valley | Holy Ghost Prep | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 1992 | Holy Ghost Prep | Quaker Valley | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 1993 | Quaker Valley | Holy Ghost Prep | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 1994 | Wyomissing | Steel Valley | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 1995 | Quaker Valley | Oley Valley | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 1996 | Quaker Valley | Wyomissing | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 1997 | Sewickley Academy | Fleetwood | 1-0, OT | Brackets |
| 1998 | Elco | Quaker Valley | 2-1, OT | Brackets |
| 1999 | Octorara | Quaker Valley | 4-1 | Brackets |
| 2000 | Quaker Valley * | Fleetwood * | 1-1 | Brackets |
| 2001 | Middletown | Thomas Jefferson | 4-0 | Brackets |
| 2002 | Thomas Jefferson | Elco | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2003 | Elco | Thomas Jefferson | 5-3 | Brackets |
| 2004 | Radnor | South Park | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 2005 | South Park | Great Valley | 1-0, OT | Brackets |
| 2006 | South Park | Manheim Central | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 2007 | Palmyra | Mars | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 2008 | Susquehannock | Pottsgrove | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 2009 | Octorara | Hampton | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 2010 | Hampton | Archbishop Wood | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 2011 | Lancaster Menonite | Tulpehocken | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 2012 | Pequea Valley | Lancaster Menonite | 1-0, 2OT | Brackets |
| 2013 | Holy Ghost Prep | West Allegheny | 1-0, OT | Brackets |
| 2014 | Holy Ghost Prep | Lancaster Menonite | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2015 | Lewisburg | South Park | 4-0 | Brackets |
| 2016 | Lewisburg | Quaker Valley | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 2017 | Quaker Valley | Lancaster Mennonite | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2018 | Fleetwood | Deer Lakes | 1-0, OT | Brackets |
| 2019 | Quaker Valley | New Hope-Solebury | 2-1 | Brackets |
| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | Score | Brackets |
| 2000 | Lewisburg | Sewickley Academy | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 2001 | Tulpehocken | Iroquois | 4-0 | Brackets |
| 2002 | Christopher Dock | Westmont Hilltop | 1-0, 2OT | Brackets |
| 2003 | Christopher Dock | Trinity Christian | 5-0 | Brackets |
| 2004 | Antietam | Trinity Christian | 4-2 | Brackets |
| 2005 | Christopher Dock | Quaker Valley | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 2006 | Seton-LaSalle | New Hope-Solebury | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2007 | Sewickley Academy | Camp Hill | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2008 | Seton-LaSalle | Camp Hill | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 2009 | Christopher Dock | Seton-LaSalle | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 2010 | New Hope-Solebury | Mercyhurst Prep | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 2011 | New Hope-Solebury | Mercyhurst Prep | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2012 | Mountain View | Sewickley Academy | 1-0 | Brackets |
| 2013 | Sewickley Academy | Mountain View | 4-2 | Brackets |
| 2014 | Moravian Academy | Sewickley Academy | 4-0 | Brackets |
| 2015 | Sewickley Academy | East Juniata | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2016 | Camp Hill | Sewickley Academy | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2017 | Camp Hill | North Catholic | 3-2, OT | Brackets |
| 2018 | Millville | Avonworth | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 2019 | Moravian Academy | Winchester Thurston | 2-0 | Brackets |