| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | Score | Brackets |
| 2000 | Upper St. Clair | Lower Merion | 4-1 | Brackets |
| 2001 | Upper St. Clair | Lower Merion | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2002 | Freedom (Dist. 11) | Lower Merion | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2003 | Upper St. Clair | Lower Merion | 5-0 | Brackets |
| 2004 | Fox Chapel | Lower Merion | 4-1 | Brackets |
| 2005 | Lower Merion | Upper Dublin | 5-0 | Brackets |
| 2006 | Peters Township | Shady Side Academy | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2007 | Shady Side Academy | Hempfield (Dist. 3) | 5-0 | Brackets |
| 2008 | North Allegheny | Shady Side Academy | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2009 | Peters Township | Upper St. Clair | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2010 | Shady Side Academy | Mt. Lebanon | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2011 | Peters Township | Shady Side Academy | 4-1 | Brackets |
| 2012 | Peters Township | Unionville | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2013 | North Allegheny | Methacton | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2014 | North Allegheny | Shady Side Academy | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2015 | North Allegheny | Shady Side Academy | 4-1 | Brackets |
| 2016 | Harriton | North Allegheny | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2017 | North Allegheny | Harriton | 4-1 | Brackets |
| 2018 | Harriton | Conestoga | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2019 | Fox Chapel | Downingtown West | 3-2 | Brackets |
| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | Score | Brackets |
| 2000 | Wyomissing | Scranton Prep | 5-0 | Brackets |
| 2001 | Wyomissing | Scranton Prep | 5-0 | Brackets |
| 2002 | Wyomissing | Harriton | 4-1 | Brackets |
| 2003 | Wyomissing | Scranton Prep | 4-1 | Brackets |
| 2004 | Harriton | Scranton Prep | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2005 | Harriton | Manheim Central | 4-1 | Brackets |
| 2006 | Harriton | Quaker Valley | 4-1 | Brackets |
| 2007 | Harriton | Quaker Valley | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2008 | Harriton | Reading Holy Name | 5-0 | Brackets |
| 2009 | Harriton | Quaker Valley | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2010 | Harriton | Wyomissing | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2011 | Sewickley Academy | Wyomissing | 5-0 | Brackets |
| 2012 | Mercyhurst Prep | Moravian Academy | 4-0 | Brackets |
| 2013 | Mercyhurst Prep | Scranton Prep | 4-1 | Brackets |
| 2014 | Mercyhurst Prep | Scranton Prep | 5-0 | Brackets |
| 2015 | Mercyhurst Prep | Beaver | 4-1 | Brackets |
| 2016 | Wyomissing | Beaver | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2017 | Villa Maria Academy | Lower Moreland | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2018 | Sewickley Academy | Wyomissing | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2019 | Sewickley Academy | Knoch | 3-0 | Brackets |