| Fall | Champion | Runner-Up | Score | Brackets |
| 2016 | Garnet Valley | Parkland | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2017 | North Allegheny | Bishop Shanahan | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2018 | North Allegheny | Bishop Shanahan | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2019 | North Allegheny | Bishop Shanahan | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2020 | North Allegheny | Unionville | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2021 | North Allegheny | Parkland | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2022 | North Allegheny | Garnet Valley | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2023 | North Allegheny | Unionville | 3-0 | Brackets |
| Spring | Champion | Runner-Up | Score | Brackets |
| 1974 | Susquehannock | Norwin | 2-1 | |
| 1975 | York Suburban | Norwin | 2-1 | |
| 1976 | Norwin | York Suburban | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1977 | Norwin | General McLane | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1978 | Norwin | General McLane | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1979 | Norwin | Kiski Area | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1980 | Norwin | Baldwin | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1981 | Norwin | Baldwin | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1982 | Norwin | Baldwin | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1983 | Norwin | Spring Grove | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1984 | Plum | North Allegheny | 2-0 | Brackets |
| Fall | ||||
| 1984 | Norwin | Seneca | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1985 | Cambria Heights | Johnstown Richland | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1986 | Norwin | Carlisle | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1987 | Norwin | Baldwin | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1988 | Norwin | Baldwin | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1989 | Baldwin | Dover | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1990 | Baldwin | Bethlehem Catholic | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1991 | Baldwin | Bethlehem Catholic | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1992 | North Allegheny | Norwin | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1993 | North Allegheny | Plum | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1994 | North Allegheny | Baldwin | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1995 | Baldwin | Dallastown | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1996 | Villa Maria Academy | Dallastown | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1997 | Mt. Lebanon | Villa Maria Academy | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1998 | Greensburg Salem | Mt. Lebanon | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1999 | Susquehannock | Mt. Lebanon | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 2000 | Mt. Lebanon | Conestoga Valley | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 2001 | Allentown C.C. | Pine-Richland | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 2002 | Villa Maria Academy | Landisville Hempfield | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 2003 | Conestoga Valley | Pennsbury | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2004 | Landisville Hempfield | Susquehannock | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2005 | Pine-Richland | Villa Maria Academy | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2006 | Landisville Hempfield | Allentown C.C. | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2007 | Allentown C.C. | Garden Spot | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2008 | Allentown C.C. | North Allegheny | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2009 | Bishop Shanahan | Allentown C.C. | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2010 | Landisville Hempfield | Upper Merion | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2011 | Parkland | Landisville Hempfield | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2012 | Landisville Hempfield | Parkland | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2013 | Landisville Hempfield | Cumberland Valley | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2014 | Parkland | Landisville Hempfield | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2015 | Parkland | Landisville Hempfield | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2016 | Allentown C.C. | Somerset | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2017 | Knoch | Allentown C.C. | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2018 | West York | Warren | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2019 | Palmyra | Southern Lehigh | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2020 | Bethlehem Catholic | Franklin Regional | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2021 | Spring Grove | Hampton | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2022 | Pope John Paul II | North Catholic | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2023 | Pope John Paul II | Hampton | 3-1 | Brackets |
| Spring | Champion | Runner-Up | Score | Brackets |
| 1982 | Farrell | Johnstown Richland | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1983 | Johnstown Richland | Farrell | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1984 | Johnstown Richland | Eastern York | 2-0 | Brackets |
| Fall | ||||
| 1984 | Johnstown Richland | Iroquois | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1985 | Maplewood | Elk County Christian | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1986 | Johnstown Richland | Elk County Christian | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1987 | Farrell | Johnstown Richland | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1988 | Elderton | Kane | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1989 | Farrell | Johnstown Richland | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1990 | Elderton | McConnellsburg | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1991 | Elderton | Conneaut Lake | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1992 | Maplewood | Farrell | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1993 | Farrell | Maplewood | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1994 | Farrell | Grove City | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1995 | Maplewood | Johnstown Richland | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1996 | Johnstown Richland | Shannock Valley | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 1997 | Shannock Valley | Farrell | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1998 | Farrell | Johnstown Richland | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 1999 | Johnstown Richland | Cochranton | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 2000 | Johnstown Richland | Maplewood | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 2001 | Merion Mercy | Delone Catholic | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 2002 | Brandywine Heights | Allentown C.C. | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 2003 | Huntingdon | Allentown C.C. | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2004 | Hopewell | Reading Holy Name | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2005 | Maplewood | Titusville | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2006 | West Allegheny | Brandywine Heights | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2007 | Merion Mercy | Maplewood | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2008 | Merion Mercy | Susquehannock | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2009 | Merion Mercy | Brandywine Heights | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2010 | Merion Mercy | West Allegheny | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2011 | Brandywine Heights | Southern Lehigh | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2012 | Fort LeBoeuf | Delone Catholic | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2013 | Delone Catholic | Fort LeBoeuf | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2014 | Bethlehem Catholic | Fort LeBoeuf | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2015 | Berks Catholic | Fort LeBoeuf | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2016 | Corry | North Star | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2017 | Freeport | Delone Catholic | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2018 | Bald Eagle Area | Holy Redeemer | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2019 | North Catholic | North Penn-Liberty | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2020 | Camp Hill Trinity | Philipsburg-Osceola | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2021 | North Catholic | Camp Hill Trinity | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2022 | Freeport | York Catholic | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2023 | Philipsburg-Osceola | Camp Hill Trinity | 3-1 | Brackets |
| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | Score | Brackets |
| 2000 | Conneaut Lake | Farrell | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 2001 | Farrell | West Shamokin | 2-1 | Brackets |
| 2002 | Farrell | Canton | 2-0 | Brackets |
| 2003 | Marian Catholic | Farrell | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2004 | Cochranton | Northern Cambria | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2005 | Northern Cambria | Marian Catholic | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2006 | Reading Central Catholic | Northern Cambria | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2007 | Reading Central Catholic | Cochranton | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2008 | Reading Holy Name | North Star | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2009 | Northern Cambria | Reading Holy Name | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2010 | Reading Holy Name | Clarion | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2011 | Linesville | Clarion | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2012 | Clarion | Williamson | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2013 | Marian Catholic | Cochranton | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2014 | Greensburg C.C. | Marian Catholic | 3-2 | Brackets |
| 2015 | Bishop Canevin | North Star | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2016 | Greensburg C.C. | Marian Catholic | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2017 | Maplewood | Marian Catholic | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2018 | Northern Cambria | Berlin Brothersvalley | 3-1 | Brackets |
| 2019 | Northern Cambria | Nativity BVM | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2020 | Clarion | Nativity BVM | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2021 | Clarion | Sacred Heart | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2022 | Maplewood | West Branch | 3-0 | Brackets |
| 2023 | Elk County Catholic | West Branch | 3-0 | Brackets |