| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | Score | Brackets |
| 1999 | Bald Eagle Area | Upper Perkiomen | 53-0 | |
| 2000 | Northampton | Connellsville | 30-19 | |
| 2001 | Easton | State College | 35-19 | Brackets |
| 2002 | Easton | Trinity (D-7) | 47-15 | Brackets |
| 2003 | Easton | Kiski Area | 43-12 | Brackets |
| 2004 | Easton | Connellsville | 39-18 | Brackets |
| 2005 | Connellsville | Easton | 34-25 | Brackets |
| 2006 | Upper Perkiomen | Easton | 46-19 | Brackets |
| 2007 | Nazareth | Easton | 40-21 | Brackets |
| 2008 | Central Dauphin | Northampton | 37-21 | Brackets |
| 2009 | Central Dauphin | Cumberland Valley | 34-30 | Brackets |
| 2010 | Central Dauphin | Parkland | 41-28 | Brackets |
| 2011 | Central Dauphin | Easton | 36-18 | Brackets |
| 2012 | Canon-McMillan | Erie McDowell | 35-20 | Brackets |
| 2013 | Canon-McMillan | Central Dauphin | 34-31 | Brackets |
| 2014 | Franklin Regional | Latrobe | 37-23 | Brackets |
| 2015 | Franklin Regional | Cumberland Valley | 36-33 | Brackets |
| 2016 | Bethlehem Catholic | Boyertown | 37-20 | Brackets |
| 2017 | Nazareth | Bethlehem Catholic | 30-29, Crit. D | Brackets |
| 2018 | Bethlehem Catholic | Kiski Area | 38-22 | Brackets |
| 2019 | Bethlehem Catholic | Northampton | 31-19 | Brackets |
| 2020 | Nazareth | Waynesburg | 38-21 | Brackets |
| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | Score | Brackets |
| 1999 | Brookville | Wyalusing | 23-21 | |
| 2000 | Wyalusing | Fort LeBoeuf | 40-16 | |
| 2001 | Wilson | Shady Side Academy | 49-15 | Brackets |
| 2002 | Wilson | Bloomsburg | 45-9 | Brackets |
| 2003 | Juniata | Brockway | 39-23 | Brackets |
| 2004 | Bloomsburg | Fort LeBoeuf | 38-26 | Brackets |
| 2005 | Northern Lehigh | Reynolds | 35-22 | Brackets |
| 2006 | Reynolds | Northern Lehigh | 38-19 | Brackets |
| 2007 | Reynolds | Northwestern Lehigh | 33-26 | Brackets |
| 2008 | Burrell | Bermudian Springs | 37-29 | Brackets |
| 2009 | Reynolds | Shady Side Academy | 42-18 | Brackets |
| 2010 | Fort LeBoeuf | Reynolds | 32-29 | Brackets |
| 2011 | Bethlehem Catholic | Fort LeBoeuf | 38-21 | Brackets |
| 2012 | Bethlehem Catholic | Boiling Springs | 52-15 | Brackets |
| 2013 | Bethlehem Catholic | Reynolds | 43-16 | Brackets |
| 2014 | Bethlehem Catholic | Reynolds | 41-15 | Brackets |
| 2015 | Boiling Springs | Chestnut Ridge | 36-21 | Brackets |
| 2016 | Brookville | Saucon Valley | 33-24 | Brackets |
| 2017 | Reynolds | Northern Lebanon | 54-18 | Brackets |
| 2018 | Reynolds | Southern Columbia | 30-25 | Brackets |
| 2019 | Reynolds | Southern Columbia | 31-23 | Brackets |
| 2020 | Reynolds | Southern Columbia | 34-27 | Brackets |